In the fast-paced world of home design, what felt “warm and welcoming” a decade ago can now scream dated. Whether you're prepping your property for resale or simply want to feel proud of your space, paying attention to outdated materials is a must in 2025.

Here’s the truth: Buyers today are savvy. They scroll through design-forward listings on Instagram and Pinterest. They binge social media and expect turnkey finishes. If your home still features the "cozy" trends of the early 2000s, you may be turning them off before they even step through the door.

Let’s dive into the top offenders—The Cozy Killers—and what to replace them with to boost value and appeal.

1. Faux Tuscan Tiles: From Rustic Charm to Resale Red Flag

Faux Tuscan tiles—especially those orange-brown ceramics with ornate patterns—were once the go-to for evoking old-world charm. But in 2025, they’re one of the biggest outdated home materials.

Why they no longer work:
Heavy, overly warm tones can make spaces feel dark and dated. Modern buyers want light, airy, and versatile finishes that work with a variety of styles.

Renovation tip for resale:
Swap them out for large-format porcelain tiles in neutral tones like soft taupe, pale greige, or stone-inspired textures. These create a timeless, upscale look—especially in kitchens and entryways.

2. Old Laminate Floors: The Budget Choice That’s Costing You Now

Laminate has come a long way, but if your floors still rock that glossy, reddish-brown finish from the late 90s or early 2000s, it's time to say goodbye.

Why it’s a resale killer:
Peeling edges, plasticky finishes, and unrealistic wood grains stand out (and not in a good way). In competitive real estate markets like Toronto, buyers expect quality—and cheap floors make your whole home feel lower-end.

Upgrade idea:
Engineered hardwood or luxury vinyl plank (LVP) in wide planks and matte finishes are dominating in 2025. They offer durability, style, and a higher-end feel that adds instant appeal.

3. Granite Countertops in Busy Patterns: The Flashy Fad That’s Faded

Granite isn’t inherently bad—but those heavily speckled, multi-colour patterns (think: black, brown, cream mashups) are no longer in vogue.

What’s changed:
Today’s homeowners lean toward simplicity and elegance. Clean surfaces like quartz or subtle marble-look finishes feel more current.

Renovation tip:
If a full countertop replacement isn’t in the budget, consider refinishing options or updating just the island for a refreshed look. Neutral, solid-tone countertops can dramatically change the tone of your kitchen.

4. Cherry or Mahogany Cabinets: Rich Wood, Outdated Finish

Deep red wood cabinetry had its moment, but in 2025, it reads as heavy and outdated—especially when paired with darker granite and Tuscan-style tiles.

Why they hurt resale:
They absorb light, making kitchens feel smaller and older. They also clash with the modern preference for light, natural materials.

Update tip:
If replacing cabinets isn’t feasible, consider painting them in soft white, sage, or even charcoal. Add sleek, modern hardware in matte black or brushed gold for a high-impact refresh.

5. Glass Block Windows: The 'Privacy' Trend That Won’t Die

Popular in 90s bathrooms and basements, glass block windows were meant to add privacy without sacrificing light. But now, they’re a surefire way to date your space.

Why it feels dated in 2025:
They break up clean lines and interrupt natural light flow. Their bulky, retro look doesn't align with contemporary design aesthetics.

Modern alternative:
Replace with frosted or textured glass panels that maintain privacy while blending seamlessly with modern architecture.

6. Heavy Textured Walls & Ceilings: A Touch Too Much

Popcorn ceilings, knockdown textures, and faux Venetian plaster walls fall squarely into the “cozy killers” category.

Why it turns buyers off:
Textured finishes trap dust, are hard to repair, and make a home feel older. Flat, smooth surfaces are now the standard in upscale homes.

Renovation tip:
Consider skim coating or hiring a pro to smooth ceilings and walls. This is especially worth it if you're prepping for resale in a competitive market.

The Takeaway: Your Cozy May Be Killing Your ROI

If you're planning to sell or simply want to enjoy your home in a more modern way, updating key materials is non-negotiable. The good news? You don’t need a full gut renovation. Small, strategic changes can make a massive difference—especially when you avoid the outdated finishes that signal “this home needs work.”

In a market where first impressions matter more than ever, don’t let cozy kill your resale value.